Saturday, October 9, 2010

Grassfed vs Organic, What Does it Mean?

My friend Rea recently asked if I would address the difference between organic beef and grassfed beef. These buzz words are everywhere we look, but what do these terms actually mean?

100% Grassfed Beef:
The term grassfed is used to explain how the cow was raised and fed. A grassfed animal was raised on pasture. At Lasater ranch the the cattle graze on a shortgrass prairie system their entire life.  Blue grama and buffalo grass are the dominant grass species present. Pronghorn, white tail deer, several species of small mammals and bison historically grazed in this ecosystem.
Lasater cattle are eating what they are designed to consume--grass and some forbs. A cow takes the cellulose in grass and turns it into protein. Jo Robinson writes about the benefits of eating pastured beef here: http://www.eatwild.com/basics.html


Grassfed beef is rich in the following: 
Vitamin E 
Beta carotene 
Good source for Conjugated Linoleic Acid (CLA) 
Healthy ratio of Omega 3 to 6 Fatty Acid 
High quality protein 
Iron, zinc, selenium, and B-complex vitamins




Lasater ranch is organic and the cattle are grazing on grass and other short grass prairie species. 
 
Organic Beef: 
Certified organic beef is born and raised without antibiotics or growth hormones. Unless organic beef is labeled grassfed it is fed grain. This is where quality and health become a concern. Cattle raised on grain, even organic, are not healthy. Cattle are herbivorous ruminants (plant eaters that chew their cud). Cows are not accustomed to consuming grains. Why are they eating such an unnatural diet? It's economically profitable to feed cows subsidized grains that serve to rapidly pack on the pounds. Grains are high in energy and can fatten up the cow a lot faster than the natural way of letting the steer roam on a pasture and eat grass. Because the corn or grain disturbs their digestion, they are more apt to get sick. The grain prevents the rumen (first division of the cow stomach) from functioning as it should, and the cow becomes more susceptible to bloating which can lead to suffocation. Grain fed cattle may also get acidosis, which is the acidifying of the rumen. Eventually the rumen is ulcerated and this can and often does lead to liver disease. Organs failing are symtoms of sick animals which translates to less healthy beef. Cattle raised on grain, even organic, are not as healthy as cattle raised on grass.  There is a very lengthy interview with Michael Pollen addressing the issue of feeding grain to cattle and health concerns here: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/meat/interviews/pollan.html


Practice discretion when buying organic beef. 100% grassfed beef is best! I hope this helps answer some questions you may have regarding these two terms.

2 comments:

  1. I bought something that was described at pasture raised, organic beef.

    Is pasture raised the same thing as grass fed?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Anonymous,
    Thank you for your question. As far I know, “pasture-raised” and “grass-fed” are not regulated phrases, meaning they can be used as broad, generic terms with ambiguous definitions. As a result, we as consumers find ourselves navigating waters that are unclear. And in some cases, to our disappointment, we may learn that these terms are being used in a misleading manner.
    When I say “pasture-raised”, or “pastured”, I mean that the cattle are raised roaming the fields. With respect to Lasater, the cattle roam in a native shortgrass prairie system, which is rich in species, and includes forbs. A forb is a vascular plant without a significant amount of woody tissue. They may be annual, biennial, or perennial.
    “Grassfed”, from my perspective, is a much broader term. It may refer to an animal that is fed grass species, with perhaps some forbs, for only a portion of their life. Also, these animals may or may not be pastured.
    According to Shannon Hayes, author of
    “The Farmer and The Grill” (http://www.grassfedcooking.com/), once you've tasted true grassfed and pastured meat flavors, your palate will easily be able to determine the difference.
    Finally, Jo Robinson, author of “Pasture Perfect” encourages consumers who want to know about their food sources to call producers directly, or better yet, visit the ranch or farm! Ask specifically where the animals are raised, what they are fed, and how they are managed.
    Lasater Grasslands Beef hosts a Field Day each year. Dale Lasater will lead us on a tour of the Ranch. Also this year, we are privileged to welcome Chip Clouse from the American Birding Association. He will join us for the day on a birding tour of the ranch. Please follow me on Twitter to know when this will happen. http://twitter.com/LasaterRanch Know your sources.

    ReplyDelete